The Making of:
Come Let Us Sing!

Volume I: Released: May 8, 2005


Everyone's doing it!   CDs are a great way to fundraise, advertise, archive, and raise group-self-esteem. But they can be full of surprises if you don't plan ahead and understand the entire scope of a seemingly simple recording session. Below are captured our experiences and advice about making a church choir CD—the perils and the joys.

In-house, staff, volunteer labor, or donated step Hire the task to be done
Set your goals. How much are you trying to raise, and what are you expecting the (proportioned) cost per CD to be. Consider a custom-made CD run of 100 to start small. If that feels like 100 is too small a run, then look at the pricing for 500. Be very careful if you set your sights on more than 500. Don't be too optimistic on sales. After the first few weeks, sales plummit. See costing info under manufacturing— Cost difference between 500 and 1000 is typically about $150. n/a

Choose a CD theme and select the music. Brainstorm a large list of possibilities and start narrowing down. Involve choir, clergy, and congregants. Consider what the choir knows best and what will sell best. Consider also the royalty fees, which are about $8.50 per track per 100 copies. Consider also having 2 or 3 tracks more than you really intend to produce, thus you can drop a few lesser-quality tracks after editing and still have a respectable-length CD (of consistently good quality).

n/a
Marketing & Advertising: Plan from the beginning how you're going to sell the CDs - don't leave 900 CDs for your successor to keep dusted in your music room. n/a
Underwriting- Consider having a donor campaign to attract underwriters to contribute (e.g., 25 people at $100 each) to cover the production and manufacturing costs. Then your sales proceeds are completely donations. Depending on your situation you may be able to obtain a grant. n/a

Assemble a dry run CD (from tapes of services, rehearsals, etc.) This is not from final recording sessions, but rather just quick recordings to get the "feel" of what will go well together and in what sequence they sound best. This also will help confirm the length of each piece and how much will fit onto your CD.
If you have a volunteer as recording engineer, it's very important that you test the entire process workflow so that you won't have spent 25 hours recording to find that the format was wrong or the levels insufficient. Make sure you know what you're doing.
Have your sample CD audience-tested by parishioners as well as critical colleagues—it's much better to get constructive criticism prior to the recording sessions.

If you don't have in-house recording possibilities, you'll need to hire someone to do a quickie taping.
Plan and execute your recording sessions-Divide up your playlist into reasonable chunks of time that will be a variety for the performers and not too taxing. The sessions can be separate times, or during/after performances (services). Plan several takes per piece so that you'll have options during editing. Be careful not to be too picky or you won't complete your playlist for that session. Consider repeating only sections of a piece (so you won't tire everyone out), but be sure to include a measure before and a measure after the section you're replacing so you can splice more easily.
Prior to the sessions, coach your performers about quietness, page turns, silence prior and after the music begins/ends, what to do if someone makes a mistake (e.g., keep going, and then later re-record that phrase/section).
A professional recording engineer will bring equipment on site and "tape" your sessions. Expect requests for sound tests, and occasionally a technical situation might require you to repeat a piece.
Depending on the number of sessions and the microphone set-up, expect to pay $500-$5000 for the sessions.
Offline Editing- The director (or musical producer) obtains raw audio (usually CDs burned from the sessions), with each track corresponding to a take. Make a xerox of all your scores and mark, per measure, which tracks are not usable (e.g., sirens, pages turning, pitch). From that, determine the best tracks to use and supply these lists for your audio editor in a graph format that is easy to refer to. See example (you shouldn't need to hire a professional)
Online editing- Using the above track strategy, edit each piece and check carefully the splices for piecewise-linearity (musical-ness as well as acoustically). Although with today's offerings of audio editors that make it easy to edit timeline-based audio tracks, you really should hire an Audio Engineer to at least consult.
Depending on the extent of editing (and changes you need to make subsequently), expect to pay $300-$2000.
Final composite (CD Mastering) - Your recording engineer will assemble the final tracks in CD format, make any final EQ adjustments, and include the spacings between tracks. Verify the final CD prior to sending to the manufacturer. Listen closely, without being disturbed and without distractions. You'll live with your decisions for many years! Unless you really know what you're doing, you must hire someone to do this. Expect to pay $100-500, assuming there's just one session of conversion and no subsequent changes.

Graphic Design- This should be done in parallel with the audio process. Collect ahead of time images and titles and personnel. Work ahead to critically review the text, since it's very expensive either in labor or delays to have changes at the last minute. Note that CD printed page "real estate" is very small and it's just not possible to put much text on the page. Keep it short.  Larger “poster foldout” inserts are available, but add $0.30 to $0.40 per disk.

Depending on the complexity and scope, a professional designer could charge $500 to $5000.
Changes really start increasing the bill!
People always come to designers saying, yes I have everything all set, and then starts the long series of corrections and afterthoughts.
Understand up-front where the costs will be: complex cover designs, costly on-CD duotone conversions/abstractions, fancy formatted tracklists. If you can find an existing CD that you like, then submit that to fashion yours after.

Pay the royalties- Musical selections that are still in copyright must have a royalty paid for mechanical reproduction. You can assign a volunteer to research the method best for your CD, and each track (for a short "anthem") costs about $0.085 per CD produced. Thus if 10 tracks are still under copyright and you produce 1000 CDs, you must pay $850 in fees, which is how composers earn a living. The license acknowledgement must be listed in the CD liner notes, and (P) (C) copyright marks in the liner and on-CD.
Many composers use the "clearinghouse" services of Harry Fox Agency so that you the CD producer make one check to the clearinghouse and they in turn distribute to the composers(or their heirs).

You can hire the services to research the royalties, but it is pretty straightforward to do.
Manufacturing- Choose your manufacturer well ahead of time and understand clearly each line item of what they will and won't do. An important aspect to consider is how much free time they offer for fix-ups once you've submitted the final package. Read carefully their FAQ list, tips list, and top-ten things people do wrong.
Often your recording engineer can recommend the best company for your needs and situation.

You could do CD burning on your own computer or buy a CD replicator, but homemade CDs do not have the reliability and inter-operability that stamp-manufactured CDs have.
Often the results look and sound homemade.

Professionally replicated and packaged (not “burned”) with color printed inserts, polywrap, and UPC barcode (usually required if you offering for sale in stores). Prices range from $1100 to $1600 for quantities of 300-1000. Runs of under 300 are almost always “burned” copies.
Web Design and audio samples- These days, it's almost a given that a web site accompanies a CD for program notes, details, further marketing, etc. This can be planned and begun in parallel with the other aspects. Encourage collaboration with the graphic designer. Although volunteers usually abound with varying degrees of web authoring skills, you can hire the services of a professional designer to adapt the information for a web site. Online sales and audio samples are recommended. In any case, have a professional look - "image" (and audio) sells!

Marketing & Advertising- Brainstorm for your geographical area and your CD theme who are the demographics that are potential buyers and how you can reach them. Don't stop just at your congregation, but target also the community and other demographic commonalities.

(not recommended to hire a professional; not needed)
CD Release party- Plan a CD release party to hype the initial selling of the CD. Include in a church service selections from the CD (both actual audio as well as live performance). Create suspense and anticipation prior to the release to enhance attendance that Sunday. Hire an expensive caterer and send the bill to the Senior Minister!   :)
Sales Tracking & storage- Ahead of time, assign a coordinator person who is good (and patient) at tracking inventory and income. (a professional is not needed)

A view into the making of Volume I:  
COME, LET US SING

Photos in the 1st U Sanctuary by David Nase


Poised in our heavenly nest, the choir spent five sessions of three hours each
to produce 13 hours of digital audio to be edited down.
Microphones are poised like a web of protective angels.


For Volume I, all except the a capella anthems were recorded in the balcony.
Bob Gordon huddles in the back left corner at the recording control center.


The organ console music rack was equipped with
a patented music-score-height-extender support
(a.k.a. cardboard)
to facilitate the large, taped-together organ scores
so the organist-director didn't have to turn pages.


"Please turn your pages quietly and no toe-tapping!"


Our patient house manager, Catherine Galbreath,
listens for sirens and trucks to warn us to re-record the track.
The center ladder supports the ambient channel microphones.

We made sure our two Steinways did not contribute sympathetic vibrations.


Bob Gordon sorts out the best of one anthem's six takes (those without trucks and sirens)
to edit down for the final CD tracks.

(Co-editor Will places his headphones on the table to snap the photo.)


Bob is amused as we edit-out yet another passing siren.

And here's what took Bob yet another 30 hours of post-production time:

(Click on above image for clearer PDF format)


First Unitarian Church
90 Main Street
Worcester, Massachusetts USA

Music at First Unitarian

1st U Original Web Site